An empty chair facing the world number one: Carlsen, the default and the limits of the arbiter
Total Chess World Championship Tour Pilot · Budapest · 17 and 18 November 2026

A board set up, a player seated and waiting, and the clock running. Her opponent, the world number one, never sits down. Fifteen minutes later, the game is declared lost.
This happened in Budapest between Magnus Carlsen and Bibisara Assaubayeva. Carlsen had already won the blitz and rapid games of that day and decided not to play the last game, the slowest one (“Fast Classic”). Something that was legal under the regulations opened a debate of great interest to arbiters: what can the arbiter do when a player decides not to show up?
What happened?
- Carlsen had won three of the four blitz games (he drew the fourth) and both rapid games. Victory for the day was already secured.
- A few minutes before the slow game, he approached the chief arbiter and asked her whether losing by default would have any additional consequence.
- He did not sit down. Assaubayeva waited at the board and, after 15 minutes, Carlsen was declared to have lost the game.
- Carlsen explained it this way: the match was already decided and the only consequence was losing a “totally meaningless” game.
- It was not so meaningless: those points left the score at 11.5–8.5, and Assaubayeva started the second day of the duel only 3 points behind.
- The next day it happened again. On Wednesday 18 November, Carlsen again failed to show up for the “Fast Classic” game and lost by default for the second time. The day ended 10–10 and Carlsen advanced to the next stage. Of the 14 games scheduled, only 12 were played.
Bibisara Assaubayeva’s response
On video: the voices of the case
His main words, in English: “There will be no classical game as I understood, the match is over. The only consequence of not showing up is that you will lose a totally meaningless game.” (as quoted by PTI)
Source: ChessBase India video on YouTube. Subtitles are switched on automatically (YouTube’s automatic captions may contain inaccuracies).
Her words: “Magnus came before the game, since he already won his match… he asked what happens in such a case. From our perspective, there is no extra penalty – except the game is -+ of course.”
Source: ChessBase India video on YouTube. Subtitles are switched on automatically (YouTube’s automatic captions may contain inaccuracies).
▶ Watch Bibisara waiting in front of the empty chair (Instagram) ↗
Video published by Sports.kz. No dialogue: it shows Bibisara in the playing hall, next to the board set up and Carlsen’s empty chair, until she gathers her things and leaves.
The key for arbiters: the arbiter applies the regulations, not public opinion
1. Defaults are regulated. The Laws of Chess (Article 6.7) state that the regulations of an event must specify a default time in advance. A player who arrives at the board after that time loses the game, unless the arbiter decides otherwise. In Budapest, that time was 15 minutes.
2. The arbiter acted correctly. She started the clock, waited for the established time and recorded the loss. When Carlsen asked beforehand, she simply explained the regulations, without advising or pressuring him. That is the correct position: the arbiter informs; she does not steer players’ sporting decisions.
“Magnus came before the game, since he already won his match… he asked what happens in such a case. From our perspective, there is no extra penalty – except the game is -+ of course.”
— Anastasia Sorokina, chief arbiter. Source: ChessBase India video interview
3. The arbiter cannot “punish what people dislike”. If the regulations of the event do not provide for additional consequences (loss of prizes, fines, expulsion), the arbiter cannot invent them. Sanctions must be written down before the tournament begins.
4. The gap lies in the regulations of the event. The format required all three time controls to be played on each day, but it did not say what would happen if a player voluntarily gave up a game that no longer mattered to him. That is the lesson for organisers and chief arbiters: good regulations anticipate these situations.
Bárbara López-Chávez’s view
Behaviour also competes
No title is above respect for the opponent. A board with a player waiting and an empty chair is not a technical detail: it is a message. And when the world number one sends it, it is received by thousands of players, arbiters and children who see him as a role model.
Being legal does not make it right. The regulations allowed him not to show up; sportsmanship asked him to sit down and play. His opponent, the public, the organisers and the competition itself deserved that game.
The example is set from the top. The bigger the name, the greater the responsibility. What a champion does is copied in club tournaments the very next day.
The rules are for everyone. Judgement cannot change depending on who sits at the board. If a conduct would not be accepted from an unknown player, it should not be applauded in a star.
The regulations say what may be done. Sportsmanship, what should be done. A great player is measured by his games; a great sportsman, also by how he treats his opponent.
To review: FIDE Laws of Chess, Articles 6.7 (default time and failure to appear) and 11.1 (conduct of the players).
Sources: ChessBase · Infobae · World Chess · ChessBase India · Interview with the chief arbiter (video) · ThePrint (PTI) · NUR.KZ · Sports.kz · FIDE Laws of Chess