The empty chair · Part three · Budapest 2026
The chief arbiter speaks: Anastasia Sorokina responds to FIDE
Arbitral authority carries obligations, but it also requires guarantees.
Illustration: Escuela Arbitral de Ajedrez · “The empty chair” series, part 3
The controversy that arose during the Total Chess World Championship Tour Pilot 2026 has a new chapter, this time in the voice of the person responsible for leading the team of arbiters.
Where we are in this series
In part one we analysed Magnus Carlsen’s default and the limits of the arbiter. In part two we presented FIDE’s official statement, which referred both the player’s conduct and the arbiters’ performance to its disciplinary bodies. Today we give a voice to the other side: the tournament’s chief arbiter.
Anastasia Sorokina’s open letter
On 21 November 2026, a few hours after FIDE’s statement, International Arbiter Anastasia Sorokina published on her X account an open letter addressed to FIDE President Timur Turlov and Deputy President Viswanathan Anand, in response to the official statement of the International Chess Federation.
In her statement, Sorokina defends the work of the tournament’s ten arbiters and rejects the public accusations that they failed to meet their professional responsibilities.
What does Anastasia Sorokina argue?
- Action in accordance with the rules. The arbiters acted in accordance with the FIDE Laws of Chess and the competition regulations, approved by FIDE jointly with Norway Chess.
- No appeals or complaints. During the tournament no appeals were lodged against arbiters’ decisions and no formal complaints were made about the team’s work.
- No prior contact. No one from FIDE contacted the chief arbiter, either during the tournament or before the statement was published, and the accusations do not identify any specific breach of the regulations.
- What she asks for. The withdrawal of the accusations, a retraction published through the same official channels as the statement, and a public apology to the arbiters.
A necessary reflection for our profession
The letter introduces a fundamental dimension: the right of arbiters to know the facts and the regulatory provisions they are being reproached for, and to present their explanations before any responsibility is determined.
Arbitral authority carries obligations, but it also requires guarantees.
The Escuela Arbitral de Ajedrez considers it important to make available to its community both FIDE’s official statement and the chief arbiter’s response. The aim is not to anticipate conclusions, but to encourage the study of the rules, respect for due process and critical analysis of arbitral responsibilities.
A question for our arbiters
Where does the individual responsibility of the player end, and where does the responsibility of the team of arbiters begin, when an obligation set out in the competition regulations is breached?The art of being a chess arbiter also means understanding, reasoning and defending decisions on solid grounds.
FIDE International Arbiter (Category B) · FIDE Lecturer
Academic Director, Escuela Arbitral de Ajedrez
The art of being a chess arbiter
Sources and further reading
- Anastasia Sorokina. Open letter to Timur Turlov and Viswanathan Anand, published on her X account (@SorokinaChess). 21 November 2026.
- FIDE. FIDE Statement on the Conclusion of the Total Chess World Championship Tour Pilot 2026. 21 November 2026.
- World Chess. FIDE’s Favorite Arbiter Would Like an Apology. November 2026.
- Part one of this series: “An empty chair facing the world number one: Carlsen, the default and the limits of the arbiter” (18 November 2026).
- Part two of this series: “After the empty chair: FIDE, the arbiters and the regulations” (21 November 2026).